JEI Home  |  JTAS  |  Email JEI  |  ISEIS  |

Journal of Environmental Informatics

Online ISSN 1684-8799 / Print ISSN 1726-2135

JEI Operating Procedure

Guideline for Reviewers

PDF   Word

online review form


Reviewer's name:

Email address:    

Manuscript Number:   


Please rate the manuscript in following categories:

Importance        Originality        Organization

Clarity               Accuracy        Methodology

Results       Interpretation          References


OVERALL RECOMMENDATION:

Accept without revision

Accept subject to minor revision

Accept with major revision

Reject but may resubmit

Reject


Comments to the editors: This part is confidential, and only presented to the editors.

 


Comments to the Author: Please do not make any specific statement about acceptability of the paper in this part.